Elastic band grippers aren't a dealbreaker at all—they're a simple, reliable way to keep your cycling pants from riding up, and they're especially common on budget-friendly options and some women's styles. The elastic sewn into the hem creates tension that holds the leg opening in place, and some versions add a silicone coating for extra grip. For casual rides, commutes, or shorter distances, they work just fine.
The tradeoff is that elastic bands can feel tighter and less refined than silicone dot or band grippers. They may roll on certain body types, and they add a bit of bulk at the hem compared to sleeker options. If you have larger thighs, pay attention to whether the elastic feels restrictive or leaves deep marks.
If you're spending long hours in the saddle or riding in hot, sweaty conditions, silicone grippers tend to be more comfortable and secure. But for the price, elastic band grippers get the job done for everyday riding.