GORE-TEX cycling shoes are a great choice if you regularly ride in wet or cold conditions. The waterproof membrane keeps rain, puddle splash, and wind out, so your feet stay dry and warm on soggy commutes, winter training rides, or multi-day bikepacking trips where you can't avoid the weather.
However, that same waterproofing comes with a trade-off: reduced breathability. In warm or hot weather, GORE-TEX shoes can trap heat and moisture inside, leaving your feet feeling hot and sweaty. They also tend to cost more and weigh a bit more than non-waterproof alternatives.
So if you mostly ride in dry, warm conditions or only occasionally get caught in the rain, you'll likely be happier with a more breathable upper like mesh, knit, or microfiber. Save the GORE-TEX shoes for the seasons and conditions where staying dry really matters.